• Home Page
  • UFO Topics
  • UFO Photos
  • UFO Cases
  • Sighting Reports
  • Report a Sighting

Article/Document:

Resources on Interstellar Probes

Interstellar-probes.org

original source |  fair use notice

Summary: This page contains a guide to the resources needed to study interstellar probes, interstellar travel, interstellar propulsion systems, the search for robotic interstellar probes or ETI probe visitation, and information on earth's robotic probes. Abstracts for the papers or the introductory text from the book, or book chapter, will be given.



RESOURCES

This page contains a guide to the resources needed to study interstellar probes, interstellar travel, interstellar propulsion systems, the search for robotic interstellar probes or ETI probe visitation, and information on earth's robotic probes. Abstracts for the papers or the introductory text from the book, or book chapter, will be given. Online links will be given to complete online papers. You are encouraged to get copies of these documents for your research activites.

This resource page is divided up into sections. The sections are numbered and the subject matter is combined based on its associated relavence. The papers in each section are listed in alphabetical order by author name, and title.

 

Interstellar Travel Resources


Forward, Robert, L., Feasibility of Interstellar Travel: A Review,
Journal of the British Interplanetary Society, Vol. 39, pp. 379-384, 1986.

Abstract - Interstellar travel is difficult, but not impossible. This review paper discusses the relative feasibility of a number of different technologies that will allow travel to the stars. It gives examples of one-way and rendezvous unmanned interstellar probe vehicles that can return data on the number and nature of the planets around the target system within less than 50 years after launch. These initial exploration probe missions will be followed by manned or robotic exploration and colonisation missions. These can range from relatively feasible long slow missions using "world ships" propelled by existing nuclear pulse or nuclear electric technologies and carrying self-producing human crews, to high risk, high speed missions using beamed power, antimatter, or interstellar ramjet technology. For the nearer stellar system, speeds of 0.1 to 0.3 the speed of light will suffice to explore the 17 nearest stellar systems with 25 visible stars and hundreds of planets in trip times comparable to a human lifetime. Some emergent high energy density technologies that are under development for other purposes, such as laser and electron beam imploded fusion and solar powered lasers and masers, show promise of providing us with propulsion technologies that will make rapid interstellar travel feasible within the foreseeable future.


Interstellar Propulsion Resources


Alcubierre, Miguel, The Warp-Drive: Hyper-Fast Travel within General Relativity,
Classical and Quantum Gravity, Vol. II, No. 5, pp. L73-L77, May 1994.

Abstract - It is shown how, within the framework of general relativity and without the introduction of wormholes, it is possible to modify a spacetime in a way that allows a spaceship to travel with an arbitarily large speed. By a purely local expansion of spacetime behind the spaceship and an opposite contraction in front of it, motion faster than the speed of light as seen by observers outside the disturbed region is possible. The resulting distortion is reminicent of the 'warp drive' of science fiction. However, just as happens with wormholes, exotic matter will be needed in order to generate a distortion of spacetime like the one discussed here.


Matloff, Gregory L., Mallove, Eugene F., Alien Starship Detectability - Bursters and Skidmarks,
IAF PAPER 88-552, 1988.

Abstract - All starships may utilize electromagnetic drag screens to decelerate to interplanetary velocities when approaching destination solar systems. Observable characteristics of exothermic starships and deceleration drag screens are reviewed. A preliminary theory for the detectability of ramjet or ram-augmented interstellar rocket or drag screen trails is developed. The applicability of planned astronomical telescopes to starship searches is briefly discussed.


Millis, Mark, Challenge to Create the Space Drive,
Journal of Propulsion and Power, Vol. 13, No. 5, pp. 577-582, 1997.

Abstract - To travel to our neighboring stars as practically as envisioned by science fiction, breakthroughs in science are required. One of these breakthroughs is to discover a self-contained means of propulsion that requires no propellant. To chart a path toward such a discovery, seven hypothetical space drives are presented to illustrate the specific unsolved challenges and associated research objectives toward this ambition. One research objective is to discover a means to asymmetrically interact with the electromagnetic fluctuations of the vacuum. Another is to develop a physics that describes inertia, gravity, or the properties of space-time as a function of electromagnetics that leads to using electromagnetic technology for inducing propulsive forces. Another is to determine if negative mass exists or if its properties can be synthesized. An alternative approach that covers the possibility that negaitve mass might not exist is to develop a formalism of Mach's principle or reformulate ether concepts to lay a foundation for addressing reaction forces and conservation of momentum with space drives.


Probe Energy Systems Resources


Search for ETI Probes Resources


Baker, Robert M. L., Jr. Observational Evidence of Anomalistic Phenomenon,
Journal of the Astronuatical Sciences, Vol. XV, No. 1., pp. 31-36, 1968.

Chapter Introductory Statement - "The data that I have reviewed and analyzed since 1954 lead me to believe that there is substantial evidence to support the claim that an unexplained phenomenon-or phenomena-is present in the environment of earth, but that it may not be "flying", may not always be "unidentified", and may not even take the form of substantive "objects". I would, therefore, prefer the label "Anomalistic Observational Phenomena" rather than "U.F.O.". In this report I will concentrate on the anomalistic observational phenomena as depicted in motion pictures, and will not attempt to support any particular hypothesis as to the source of the phenomenon."


Betinis, E. J., On ETI Alien Probe Flux Density,
Journal of the British Interplanetary Society, Vol. 31, pp. 217-221, 1978.

Abstract - An alien probe diffusion equation and corresponding alien probe flux density are developed to see if earth or the Solar System is being detected by technologically advanced extraterrestrial civilisations. If such is the case, then data in the form of observed probes, anomalous and alien as they may be, may possibly be reconciled with data gathered by earth-based observers.


Bracewell, Prof. Ronald N., Communications from Superior Galactic Communities,
Nature, Vol. 186, No. 4726, pp. 670-671, 1960.

Introductory paragraph - Since Morrison and Cocconi published the suggestion that there might be advanced societies elsewhere in the Galaxy, superior to ourselves in technological development, who are beaming transmissions at us on a frequency of 1,420 MHz/s., Drake has described equipment under construction to look for such transmissions. The confidence necessary to commence actual observations is based on an opinion that planets are a common by-product of the formation of starts. One argument among others is that stars of spectral type later than F5 have low angular momenta, just as the Sun has; and in the case of the Sun we know that it is because the momentum (98 per cent of it) resides in planets. Of the thousands of millions of planets in the Galaxy likely to be situated similarly to the Earth in relation to their star, it is hard to dismiss the possibility that some have more advanced civilizations than ours. In view of the acceleration with which technology develops, advanced societies could be incredibly more advanced.


Bracewell, Prof. Ronald N., Communications from Superior Galactic Communities,
Nature, Vol. 186, No. 4726, pp. 670-671, 1960.

Introductory paragraph - Since Morrison and Cocconi published the suggestion that there might be advanced societies elsewhere in the Galaxy, superior to ourselves in technological development, who are beaming transmissions at us on a frequency of 1,420 MHz/s., Drake has described equipment under construction to look for such transmissions. The confidence necessary to commence actual observations is based on an opinion that planets are a common by-product of the formation of starts. One argument among others is that stars of spectral type later than F5 have low angular momenta, just as the Sun has; and in the case of the Sun we know that it is because the momentum (98 per cent of it) resides in planets. Of the thousands of millions of planets in the Galaxy likely to be situated similarly to the Earth in relation to their star, it is hard to dismiss the possibility that some have more advanced civilizations than ours. In view of the acceleration with which technology develops, advanced societies could be incredibly more advanced.


Burke-Ward, Richard, Possible Existence of Extraterrestrial Technology in the Solar System,
Journal of the British Interplanetary Society, Vol. 53, pp. 2-12, 2000.

Cornet, Bruce and Stride, Scot L.,
Solar System SETI Using Radio Telescope Arrays
Proceedings of SETICon 03, The Third SETI League Technical Symposium,
The College of New Jersey, Ewing New Jersey, April 25-27, 2003
Online Paper (PDF 2.2 MB)
April 25th, 2003 Viewgraph Presentation (PDF 7.2 MB)
Contact in Context Paper
Online CIC Paper (PDF 1.1 MB)

Email: Cornet, Bruce
bcornet@monmouth.com
Email: Stride, Scot L.
scot.stride@verizon.net

Abstract
The search for extraterrestrial intelligence must include complementary observing programs that investigate our solar system and near Earth. Solar system observing strategies involve a search for energy (e.g., artificial microwaves) or physical manifestations (e.g., exploratory robotic probes) that may be present. Artificial electromagnetic emissions from robotic probes may be detectable using existing ground-based radio-telescope observatories like Arecibo, or those undergoing construction such as the Allen Telescope Array (ATA). Future systems like the SETI League's Array2k and the SETI Institute's ATA are well suited to the task of searching the solar system for anomalous microwave phenomena. Steerable phased arrays have the unique ability to produce multiple beams, and shaped antenna patterns to target and track specific planet-moon systems or regions of deep space. At distances less than 50 AU, large SETI arrays can detect electromagnetic emissions much fainter than those from light years away. Lower free space attenuation (i.e., higher signal-to-noise ratios), a reduced amount of scintillation from the interstellar medium, and other factors improve system performance. Solar System SETI is a search for active exploratory robotic probes within the solar system. These probes can possibly be discovered if they emit secondary or leakage microwave energy. The radial velocity, range and location of these emissions can be estimated from analysis of measured one-way doppler drifts and data from a synthesized quad-beam monopulse antenna array configuration.

Keywords: SETI, Allen Telescope Array, ATA, Solar System SETI, S3ETI, SETA, SETV, Artifacts, Exploratory Robotic Probes, Doppler, Monopulse.

Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Searching Our Solar System
     2.1 Focusing the SETI More Inward
3. Current Perspectives on ETI Motives and Observable Manifestations
    3.1 Working Assumptions
    3.2 Observable Manifestations of ETI
    3.3 Searching for Manifestations of ETI in the Solar System
    3.4 A Search for Anomalous Microwave Phenomena
4. The Application of Radio Telescope Arrays to Solar System SETI
    4.1 Characteristics and Capabilities of the Allen Telescope Array
    4.2 An S3ETI Observing Strategy Utilizing the Allen Telescope Array
      4.2.1 Doppler Correlations
      4.2.2 Single Beam Observations
      4.2.3 Multiple Beam Observations
      4.2.4 Signal-to-Noise Ratio Advantages
      4.2.5 AMP Signal Verification
    4.3 Targets of Opportunity
      4.3.1 Observations of Individual Planet-Moon Systems
      4.3.2 Observations of Multiple Planet-Moon Systems
    4.4 ATA S3ETI Research Proposals
5. Summary
6. Acknowledgements
7. Glossary of Terms
8. References
Deardorff, J. W., Possible ExtraTerrestrial Strategy for Earth,
Royal Astronomical Society, Quarterly Journal, Vol. 27, pp. 94-10, 1986.

Abstract - A hypothesis concerning the nature of extraterrestrial messages to the earth is proposed. The hypothesis is based on the following assumptions about (1) that they exist in abundance in the Galaxy; (2) that they are benevolent toward earth-based life forms, and (3) that the lack of any human detection of extraterrestrials is due to an embargo assigned to prevent any premature disclosure of their existence. It is argued that any embargo not involving alien force must be a leaky one designed to allow a gradual disclosure of the alien message and its gradual acceptance on the part of the general public over a very long time-scale. The communication may take the form of what is now considered magic, and may therefore be misinterpreted as 'magic' by or a hoax by contemporary governments and scientists.


Devito, C. L., Oehrle, R. T., A Language Based on the Fundamental Facts of Science,
Journal of the British Interplanetary Society, Vol. 43, pp. 561-568, 1990.

Abstract - The problem of how to communicate with the members of an alien society has been discussed by many authors but only one, Freudenthal, has constructed a language for this purpose. Freudenthal assumes nothing other than the ability to reason as humans do and, because he assumes so little, it is necessary to communicate a great deal about the language itself before being able to communicate any interesting information. The problem is here approached differently. Since it is likely that contact between the civilization and an alien one would be via radio, potential correspondents would have a basic knowledge of science. Such beings should therefore be able to learn a language based on fundamental science. It is assumed, more specifically, that the correspondents can count, understand chemical elements, are familiar with the melting and boiling behavior of a pure substance and understand the properties of the gaseous state. All this should be known to any society capable of developing the radio telescope. By systematically using this common knowledge one can communicate notation for numbers and chemical elements and then communicate the basic physical units; i.e., the gram, the calorie, the degree (Kelvin), etc. Once this is done more interesting information can be exchanged.


Fiebag, Johannes, Communication with Extraterrestrial Intelligences - Possibilities, Chances and
Perspectives with Special Attention given to the Leaky-Embargo Hypothesis
Journal Astronautik, Vol. 26, pp. 115-118, 1989.

Abstract - Present SETI projects are described, emphasizing search methods alternative to investigations in the radio range. The possibility that the human race is being studied by alien presences within the solar system is addressed in the context of the 'zoo hypothesis' and the 'leaky embargo' hypothesis. In the former, the aliens prevent any contact with humans, while in the latter occasional contact is permitted.


Freitas, R. A., and Valdes, F., A Search for Natural or Artificial Objects Located at the Earth-Moon Libration Points,
Icarus, Vol. 42, pp. 442-447, 1980.

Abstract - Photographs in the vicinity of the Earth-Moon triangular libration points L4 and L5, and of the solar-synchronized positions in the associated halo orbits (A. A. Kamel, 1969, Ph.D. dissertation, Stanford University), were made during August-September 1979, using the 30-in Cassegrain telescope at Leuschner Observatory, Lafayette, California. An effective 2° square field was covered at each position. No discrete objects, either natural or artificial, were found. The detection limit was about 14th magnitude. The present work extends traditional SETI observations to include the search for interstellar probes.


Freitas, R. A., and Valdes, F., A Search for Objects Near the Earth-Moon Lagrangian Points,
Icarus, Vol. 53, pp. 453-457, 1983.

Abstract - Abstract - A photographic search of the five Earth-Moon Lagrangian positions included the solar-synchro-nized positions in the stable L4/L5 libration orbits, the potentially stable nonplanar orbits near L1/L2, Earth-Moon L3, and also L2 in the Sun-Earth system. Observations using the 61-cm Burrell Schmidt telescope at the Warner and Swasey Observatory, Kitt Peak Station, spanned 60° along the lunar orbital plane x 5° around Earth-Moon L5, 48" x 5° around L4, 25° x 13° around L3, 15° x 24° around the Moon (LI/L2). and 14° x 14° around Sun-Earth L2. Limiting magnitude for the detection of libration objects near L3, L4, and L5 was 17-19th magnitude, 10-18th magnitude for L!/L2 plates, and 14-16th magnitude for Sun-Earth L2. No natural or artificial objects were found. An automated search of selected priority plates was attempted using the Faint Object Classification and Analysis System (FOCAS) software package.


Freitas Jr., Robert A., A Self-Reproducing Interstellar Probe
Journal of the British Interplanetary Society, Vol.33, pp. 251-264, 1980.

Abstract - Bracewell and Frietas have discussed the possible superiority of interstellar probes in missions of galactic exploration and recently Calder and Boyce have raised the issue of self-organizing machines in related contexts. In this paper a preliminary sketch of a self-reproducing starprobe is presented, with generation time ~103 years given a ~10-fold improvement in current human space/manufacturing technology.


Valdes, F., and Freitas, R. A., Comparison of Reproducing and Non-Reproducing Starprobe Strategies for Galactic Exploration,
Journal of the British Interplanetary Society, Vol. 33, pp. 402-408, 1980.

Abstract - Bracewell has suggested the use if nonreproducing messenger probes for interstellar exploration, and Freitas has examined the feasibility of self-reproducing automated devices in the same context. The present paper compares reproducing and nonreproducing strategies for missions of interstellar and galactic discovery. Self-reproducing probes are found to be the method of choice for active exploration programs lasting >106 years, involving searches of >106 target stars to distances > 1000 light-years in the Galactic Disk, and are superior to one-shot "Bracewell Probes" for searches of >103 stars to distances > 100 light-years in the Galactic Disk. Any nonreproducing alien probes discovered in the Solar System during the normal course of future SETI research would most likely have been sent by extraterrestrial civilizations located within a approx. 1000 light-year radius of the Sun, whereas any self-reproducing devices similarly detected probably originated far outside the exploration sphere.


Freitas, R. A., Extraterrestrial Intelligence in the Solar System: Resolving the Fermi Paradox,
Journal of the British Interplanetary Society, Vol. 36, pp. 496-500, 1983.

Abstract - The assertion that extraterrestrial intelligences (ETI) do not exist based on the apparent contradictions inherent in the Fermi Paradox, rests upon an unproven and untenable presumption: That ETI are not now present in the Solar System. Most advanced civilisations also would be either invisible or unrecognisable using current human observational methods, so millions of advanced societies may exist and still not be directly detectable by us. Thus the Fermi Paradox cannot logically be raised as an objection to the existence of ETI until these major observational deficiencies have been corrected.


Freitas, R. A. Jr., If They Are Here, Where Are They? Observational and Search Considerations,
Icarus Vol. 55, pp. 337-343, 1983.

Abstract - This paper discusses observational considerations in a search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI) program to detect extraterrestrial messenger probes in the solar system. Observable artifacts will most likely be found in a search space consisting of geocentric, selenocentric, Earth-Moon Libration, and Earth-Moon Halo orbits, which may be searched to a limiting artifact size of 110 m (pv = 0.1) using existing or foreseeable instrumentation.


Freitas Jr., Robert A., Interstellar Probes: A New Approach to SETI
Journal of the British Interplanetary Society, Vol. 33, pp. 103-109, 1980.

Abstract --Interstellar transmissions via energy-markers (photons) or matter-markers (probes) appear to be energetically indistinguishable alternatives for advanced technical societies. Since only Type II and Type III civilizations realistically can afford beacons or starprobe technology, alternative distinguishability criteria suggest the possible superiority of intelligent artifacts for contact and communication missions among extraterrestrial cultures. A balanced, more cost-effective Search for ExtraTerrestrial Intelligence (SETI) strategy is proposed.


Freitas Jr., Robert A., Valdes, Francisco,The Search for Extraterrestrial Artifacts (SETA),
Acta Astronautica, Vol. 12, No. 12, pp. 1027-1034, 1985.

Abstract - The rationale for the use of interstellar artifacts by intelligent life in the universe is described. The advantages of using interstellar probes as a means of exploration and communication are presented and shown to be significant enough to counter the time, energy, and technology arguments generally raised against contact via extraterrestrial artifacts. Four classes of artifacts are defined: Those seeking contact, those seeking to avoid contact, those intended to provide a passive technological threshold for detection, and those for which detection is irrelevant. The Search for Extraterrestrial Artifacts (SETA) is based on the latter two classes. Under the assumption that an extraterrestrial probe will be interested in life in our solar system, a near-Earth search space is defined. This search space is accessible to us now with ground and satellite observing facilities. The current observational status of SETA is reviewed and contrasted with the achievable detection limits for the different parts of the search space.


Freitas, R. A., The Search for Extraterrestrial Artifacts (SETA),
Journal of the British Interplanetary Society, Vol. 36, pp. 501-506, 1983.

Abstract - The Artifact Hypothesis states that an advanced extraterrestrial intelligence has undertaken a long-term programme of galactic exploration via the transmission of material artifacts. An attempt to verify this hypothesis experimentally, the search for extraterrestrial artifacts (SETA), is proposed to detect such evidence in the Solar system by telescopic, radar, infrared, direct probe, or other available means.


Freitas, R. A., The Case for Interstellar Probes,
Journal of the British Interplanetary Soc., Vol. 36, pp. 490-495, 1983.

Abstract - Interstellar spacecraft are superior to electromagnetic wave propagation for extrasolar exploration and communication. The search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI) should include a search for extraterrestrial probes. Arguments favouring, and various traditional objections to, interstellar communications via messenger probe are critically reviewed.


Freitas, R. A, Jr. There Is No Fermi Paradox
Icarus, Vol. 62, pp. 518-520, 1985.

Abstract - The "Fermi Paradox," an argument that extraterrestrial intelligence cannot exist because it has not yet been observed, is a logical fallacy. This "paradox" is a formally invalid inference, both because it requires modal operators lying outside the first-order propositional calculus and because it is unsupported by the observational record.


Hart, Michael H. , An Explanation for the Absence of Extraterrestrials on Earth,
Quarterly Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society, Vol. 16, pp. 128-135, 1975.

Abstract - Four categories of facts are explored for explaining the lack of observable extraterrestrial beings (ETs) on earth. The physical reasons are suggested to be the long travel times required by sublight-velocity spaceships, a problem that may be overcome by beings that live several millennia or that can be stored and reproduced from zygotes on arrival. Also, the energy requirements for interstellar travel, though large, are not an insurmountable difficulty. Sociologically, it is suggested that ETs have no interest in space travel, or they may have destroyed themselves with atomic wars, or the earth is being used as a wildlife preserve. No procedures exist to test these hypotheses, however. The consideration that ETs have not yet had time to find earth is discounted by calculations that show that another intelligent species in the Galaxy would have found earth if their space exploration efforts began at least 2,000,000 yr ago. It is concluded that if the earth has not yet been visited, then colonization of the Galaxy will most probably be done by humans, who may have the first advanced civilization in the Galaxy.


Haviland, R. P., On Communications with Extra-Terrestrial or Alien Intelligences,
Journal of the British Interplanetary Society, Vol. 28, pp. 161-167, 1975.

Abstract - The discussion deals with two questions: assuming a signal has been detected, does the signal contain a message. If so, how can it be deciphered. The concept of the message as a statistical variate is explained. When the suspected sequence of elements is examined for randomness, if any departure from randomness is found, the presence of a message is indicated. Detection of several independent organizations approaches proof of the existence of a message. In answer to the second question, some linguistic concepts are brought forward. A common experience and accord on a symbol for that experience are required for communications. Interspecies experiential differences make the first condition difficult to meet. It is argued that the frequency of the hydrogen line would constitute such a commonality. A search for a beacon frequency could commence not at integral multiples of this frequency, but at multiples by some universal constant, such as pi or e. A hypothetical interstellar message is given which first gives the code, i.e., Morse, in terms of number symbols, a likely common ground; then transmits the number pi in those symbols; then repeats the message.


Hynek, J. Allen, Unusual Aerial Phenomena,
Journal of the Optical Society of America, Vol. 43, no. 4, pp. 311-314, April 1953.

Abstract - Over a period of years, diverse aerial sightings of an unusual character have been reported. On the assumption that the majority of these reports, often made in concert, come from reputable persons, and in the absence of any universal hypotheses for the phenomena which stimulated the reports, it becomes a matter of scientific obligation and responsibility to examine the reported phenomena seriously despite their seemingly fanciful character. Accordingly, several hundred serious reports of "unidentified aerial objects" have been studied in detail in an attempt to get a pattern classification. It appears that those reported phenomena which do not admit of a ready and obvious explanation exhibit fairly well-defined patterns and that these are worthy of further study. One pattern in particular, that of a hovering nocturnal light, does not appear to be readily explainable on an astronomical basis or by mirages balloons or by conventional aircraft.


Kardashev, Nikolai S., Transmission of Information by Extraterrestrial Civilizations
Soviet Astronomy-AJ, Vol. 8, pp. 217-220, 1964.
Klaes, Larry, Where Are They?
SETI Quest Magazine, Vol. 1, No. 2, 1997.

Introductory paragraph -One of the fundamental questions in the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) is the deceptively simple-worded "Where are they?". In certain respects it is an even more pertinent query than "What are they?" For SETI to succeed, we first need to know where alien intelligence exists in the Milky Way galaxy and the locations of their signals and artifacts-which may or may not be in the same places. Pondering the makeup of extraterrestrial beings is important, but until we actually detect them, the true constitution of alien life forms will remain only speculation.


Kuiper, T.B.H, and Morris, M., Searching for Extraterrestrial Civilizations,
Science, Vol. 196, pp. 616-621, 1977.

A concerted, national, and perhaps international, effort to find radio signals from extraterrestrial civilizations (ETC's) will probably be started within the next few years. It will be the outcome of nearly 20 years of smaller searches at various radio observatories (1) and about a decade of preliminary planning for a dedicated facility (2). One major study conducted by Stanford University and NASA Ames Research Center (3) resulted in the design for an array of up to 1000 antennas of 100-meter aperture. The search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI) has bee identified in "Outlook for Space" (4) as one of the possible future tasks for the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (objective 125) and the large receiving array as one of the prerequisites (system 4010).
1. For a review of various search programs that have been conducted, see C.Sagan and F. Drake, Sci. Am. 233, 83 (May 15)
2. Final Report of the Science Workshop on Interstellar Communication, NASA Spec. Publ., in preparation.
3. Project Cyclops (Report CR114445, NASA Ames Research Center, Moffett Field, Calif., 1971)
4. "Outlook for Space," NASA Spec. Publ. SP-386 1976.


Kuiper, Thomas, B.H, and (JPL) and Brig, Glen David (Heritage Research), Searching for Extraterrestrial Civilizations,
American Journal of Physics (ISSN 0002-9505), Vol. 57, pp. 12-18, 1989.

Abstract - This resource letter provides a guide to the literature about intelligent life beyond the human sphere of exploration. It offers a starting point for professionals and academics interested in participating in the debate about the existence of other technological civilizations or in SETI.


Geoffrey A., Landis, The Fermi Paradox: An Approach Based on Percolation Theory
Journal of the British Interplanetary Society, Vol. 51, pp. 163-166, 1998.

Abstract - If even a very small fraction of the hundred billion stars in the galaxy are home to technological civilizations which colonize over interstellar distances, the entire galaxy could be completely colonized in a few million years. The absence of such extraterrestrial civilizations visiting Earth is the Fermi paradox.

A model for interstellar colonization is proposed using the assumption that there is a maximum distance over which direct interstellar colonization is feasable. Due to the time lag involved in interstellar communications, it is assumed that an interstellar colony will rapidly develop a culture independent of the civilization that originally settled it.

Any given colony will have a probability P of developing a colonizing civilization, and a probability (1-P) that it will develop a non-colonizing civilization. These assumptions lead to the colonization of the galaxy occuring as a percolation problem. In a percolation problem, there will be a critical value of the percolation probability, Pc. For P < Pc, colonization will always terminate after a finite number of colonies. Growth will occur in "clusters," with the outside of each cluster consisting of non-colonizing civilizations. For P > Pc, small uncolonized voids will exist, bounded by non-colonizing civilizations. When P is on the order of Pc, arbitrarily large filled regions exist, and also arbitrarily large empty regions.


Lawton, A. T., Infrared Interstellar Communication,
Spaceflight, Vol. 13, No. 3, pp. 83-85, 1971.
Martin, Anthony, B., Bond, Allen Is Mankind Unique in the Galaxy?
American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, IAF Paper 84-239, pp. 221-222, October 1984.

Introductory paragraphs - If intelligent life is a common occurrence in the Galaxy, then many civilizations should have arisen which by now are far in excess of mankind in both their age and their capabilities. It is to be expected on technical grounds that some of these should have crossed the threshold of their home planetary system and ventured out into interstellar space. In a time that is short when measured against astronomical timescales such civilizations could have colonized the planets orbiting every suitable star in the Galaxy.

As the Solar System is relatively young in the Galaxy, there should never have been a time in our history when mankind was not aware of the presence of such civilizations. And yet, we apparently see no signs of intelligent life in the Galaxy other than ourselves.

This paradox, now well known, was first expressed by Enrico Fermi 40 years ago, and today is still as relevant to discussions on the possible existence of intelligent life in the Universe and the methods of searching for signs of such life as it was then.

The authors have reviewed the many aspects of the Fermi Paradox for the last decade, and have recently entered the debating chamber. This present paper is an attempt to further contribute to that debate by exploring some of the arguments prompted by the Paradox in more detail than we have previously commented on. We emphasize that we are participating in a debate which has been underway for several years now, and which has well-developed arguments covered in depth in the literature. It is our hope that, by elaborating some of the key concepts which we find persuasive, we will cause the debate to refocus on the Paradox that Fermi identified so many years ago.


Martin-Smith, Dr Michael, BSc, MRCGP, FBIS A Cause and Solution for Fermi'a Paradox
American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics (AIAA), 1999.

Abstract - Fermi's Paradox is set out, and related to Drake's Equation for the probability of communicating Extraterrestrial civilizations. The terms are described, leaving the lifespan of a technological civilization as the most important. Factors affecting this term (V) are outlined, with reference to asteroid impacts. The asteroid impact threat is discussed in terms of its nature, and implications for Space development. Survival strategies for particular cultures here on Earth are described. Two extreme cases - one of isolation - the aboriginals of Australia, and the other, one of dispersal, dynamism, and belief in future Destiny - Judaism - are contrasted. It is shown that, for advanced liberal human civilization, Diaspora works and is most likely to ensure development. A proposed solution to the threat from Fermi's Paradox for our emerging civilization is dispersal backed by belief in a Cosmic Destiny for Humankind. If we are alone in the Galaxy, this is necessary for further Evolution; if not, Humanity's contribution to an overall future Galactic civilization requires expansion into Space. This rationale for space development should be adopted by the Space community. Outreach efforts by the author and associates are described.


McLaughlin, William, I., A SETI Experiment,
Journal of the British Interplanetary Society, Vol. 39, pp. 325-326, 1986.

Abstract - In order to increase the probability of contact in the search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI) it has been proposed to search more intensively in certain regions of the electromagnetic spectrum ("the water hole"). The present paper describes a similar narrowing of the search in the time domain. Application of this strategy results in the SETI experiment of searching for signals from the Tau Ceti system late in 1986 and early in 1987 and the Epsilon Eridani system in mid 1988.


Papagiannis, M. D., Are We Alone or Could They be in the Asteroid Belt?,
Quarterly Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society, Vol. 19, pp. 277-281, 1978.

Abstract - The observations that life has a natural tendency to expand into all available space, that advanced technological civilizations should be able to engage with relative ease in interstellar travelling, and that once this threshold is crossed the complete colonization of the entire Galaxy will be accomplished in a very short interval relative to the age of the Galaxy, lead us to the following dilemma: either the entire Galaxy is teeming with intelligent life and hence our solar system must have been colonized hundreds of millions of years ago, or there are no other inhabitants in our solar system and hence most probably neither any-where else in the Galaxy. Before accepting, however, the bleak verdict that we are all alone in the Galaxy, we must search carefully throughout the solar system for any signs of other technological civilizations. The most logical place to look for them seems to be the asteroid belt because of the many advantages it offers to a galactic society living in space colonies.


Power, T. S., Inspection of Alien Satellites
American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, pp. 9-12, 1963.
Regis, E., Jr., ExtraTerrestrials: Science and Alien Intelligence,
Cambridge and New York, Cambridge University Press, p. 288, 1985.

Abstract - Scientific and philosophical issues related to the search for extraterrestrial intelligence (ETI) are examined. The possible existence and nature of ETI, extraterrestrial epistemology, and a solipsist approach to ETI are discussed. Consideration is given to the detectability and decipherability of extraterrestrial communications, the design of a language for cosmic communication, and the meaning and consequences of contact.


Santoli, Salvatore, How far could we make ourselves understood by the Andromedans?
- An evolutionary cybernetic problem in hierarchical dynamics
Journal: British Interplanetary Society, Vol. 47, Issue 1, pp. 11-16, 1994.

Abstract -The mechanistic interpretation of the communication process between cognitive hierarchical systems as an iterated pair of convolutions between the incoming discrete time series signals and the chaotic dynamics (CD) at the nm-scale of the perception (energy) wetware level, with the consequent feeding of the resulting collective properties to the CD software (symbolic) level, shows that the category of quality, largely present in Galilean quantitative-minded science, is to be increasingly made into quantity for finding optimum common codes for communication between different intelligent beings. The problem is similar to that solved by biological evolution, of communication between the conscious logic brain and the underlying unfelt ultimate extralogical processes, as well as to the problem of the mind-body or the structure-function dichotomies. Perspective cybernated nanotechnological and/or nanobiological interfaces, and time evolution of the 'contact language' (the iterated dialogic process) as a self-organising system might improve human-alien understanding.


Schwartzman, D. W., The absence of extraterrestrials on earth and the prospects for CETI,
Icarus, Vol. 32, pp. 473-475, Dec. 1977.
Seeger, C. L. The Recognition of Extraterrestrial Artificial Signals,
Asilomar Conference on Circuits, Systems, and Computers, 13th, Pacific Grove, Calif., Nov. 5-7, 1979,
Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc., pp. 18-22, 1980.

Abstract - Considerations in the design of receivers for the detection and recognition of artificial microwave signals of extraterrestrial origin are discussed. Following a review of the objectives of SETI and the probable reception and detection characteristics of extraterrestrial signals, means for the improvement of the sensitivity, signal-to-noise ratios and on-line data processing capabilities of SETI receivers are indicated. The characteristics of the signals likely to be present at the output of an ultra-low-noise microwave receiver are then examined, including the system background noise, terrestrial radiations, astrophysical radiations, accidental artificial radiations of terrestrial origin, and intentional radiations produced by humans and by extraterrestrial intelligence. The classes of extraterrestrial signals likely to be detected, beacons and leakage signals, are considered, and options in the specification of gating and thresholding for a high-spectral resolution, high-time-resolution signal discriminator are indicated. Possible tests for the nonhuman origin of a received signal are also pointed out.


Steel, Duncan, SETA and 1991 VG
The Observatory, Vol. 115, No. 1125, pp. 78-83, April 1995.

Abstract - A ~ 10-metre object on a heliocentric orbit, now catalogued as 1991 VG, made a close approach to the Earth in 1991 December, and was discovered a month before perigee with the Spacewatch telescope at Kitt Peak. Its very Earth-like orbit and observations of rapid brightness fluctuations argue for it being an artificial body rather than an asteroid. None of the handful of man-made rocket bodies left in heliocentric orbits during the space age have purely gravitational orbits returning to the Earth at that time, and in any case the a priori probability of discovery for 1991 VG was very small, of order one in 100,000 per anmun. In addition, the small perigee distance observed might be interpreted as an indicator of a controlled rather than a random encounter with the Earth, and thus it might be argued that 1991 VG is a candidate as an alien probe observed in the vicinity of our planet.


Stride, Scot L., Instrument Technologies for the Detection of Extraterrestrial Interstellar Robotic Probes
SPIE Proceedings on Optical SETI-III, Vol. 4273, San Jose, California, 2001.
Online Paper
January 24th, 2001 Viewgraph Presentation (PDF 1.42 MB)
Scot L. Stride
Jet Propulsion Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
Pasadena, CA, USA
Email:
scot.stride@jpl.nasa.gov

Abstract
In the continuing endeavor to detect evidence of ETI (Extraterrestrial Intelligence) in the solar neighborhood, instrument technologies now exist that allow the formation of a scientific method to carry out a search for interstellar robotic probes of possible extraterrestrial origin. The range of currently observable probe features/manifestations will be shown and how they influence search space, instrument selection and deployment. Autonomous instrument platforms (i.e. robotic observatories) to search for anomalous energy signatures can be designed and assembled using Commercial off-the-shelf (COTS) hardware and software. The COTS approach to observatory design provides an economical, flexible and robust path toward collecting reliable data. The present variety of COTS instruments permits the necessary observational sensitivity, bandwidth and embedded processing speed to establish a nearby robotic probe detection envelope. A survey of these instrument technologies will be presented and how they can be applied to the challenge of collecting enough scientific data on anomalous observational phenomena to determine whether or not a robotic probe was detected.

Keywords: SETI, OSETI, interstellar probes, instruments, sensors, embedded computing, detection platforms.

Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Rationale to Search for Robotic Probes
     Figure 1. Actual Robotic Probe Launches and Future Projections
3. Possible ETI Robotic Probe Features
    Table 1. Large Scale Manifestations
    Table 2. Observable Manifestations
    Table 3. Factors of Limited Significance
4. Search Methodology
    Table 4. Search Methodology Steps
5. Instrument Technologies Available to Detect ETI Probe Features
    5.1 COTS Instruments
      Table 5. COTS Instrument Selection
    5.2 COTS Sensors
      Table 6. COTS Sensors Selection
    5.3 COTS Computer Hardware
      Table 7. COTS Computer Hardware Selection
    5.4 COTS Software
      Table 8. COTS Software Selection
      Figure 2. Automated Robotic Observatory Basic System Block Diagram
6. Proof is not Real-Time
7. Conclusions
References
Stride, Scot L., An Instrument-Based Method to Search for Extraterrestrial Interstellar Robotic Probes
Journal of the British Interplanetary Society, Vol. 54, No. 1/2, pp. 2-13, 2001.
Email:
scot.stride@jpl.nasa.gov

Abstract
Technological advancements have allowed us to build robotic space probes to remotely explore the solar system. Interstellar robotic missions are under serious consideration. Advanced extant extraterrestrial civilizations within the galaxy, if they exist, are very likely exploring with robotic probes as well, some of which may have reached our solar system and taken an interest in life on Earth. Recent technological advances make it possible to conduct a scientific search for evidence of extraterrestrial interstellar robotic probes. Modern solid-state sensing devices and scientific instruments, combined with high-speed computer hardware, can be used in an effort to detect the physical presence of a probe. The SETV (Search for Extraterrestrial Visitation) model is new and an offspring of SETA (artifacts) and SETI. SETV includes the construction of passive autonomous data acquisition platforms using "commercial off-the-shelf" hardware, to collect reliable and unambiguous data on anomalous observational phenomena that may be ETI probes. The SETV hypothesis and experimental methods will be described. The SETV hypothesis can be experimentally tested and attempts to statistically reject a null hypothesis which states that ETI probes do not exist. SETV Pre and Post-detection protocols are necessary and will be examined. SETV is a timely, results-oriented, method worthy of serious consideration in our continuing desire to answer the question "Are we alone?"

Keywords: SETI, Interstellar robotic probes, SETV, SETA, COTS, Instruments, Sensors, Automated smart surveillance

Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Autonomous ETI Probes and their missions
     Figure 1. Russian Luna 1 Space Probe (circa 1959)
3. The SETV Experiment
    3.1 Placement of an Experimental Platform
    3.2 Description of an Experimental Platform
       Figure 2. ETP Scanning Polycamera System Block Diagram
    3.3 Related Observational Experiments, AOP and DATA Analysis
       Figure 3. Hypothetical Cladogram
    3.4 SETV Protocols
4. Conclusion
5. Acknowledgements
References


Stull, M.A., On the Significance of the Apparent Absence of Extraterrestrials on Earth
Journal of the British Interplanetary Society, Vol. 32, pp. 221-222, 1979.

Abstract -Arguments that even a single extraterrestrial civilization would have long ago colonized the Galaxy are not compelling. Many factors, including intraspecific competition, could prevent complete colonization, except, perhaps, on time scales much greater than 1010 years. It follows that the fact that extraterrestrial civilizations do not appear to be represented on Earth is irrelevant to the formulation of plans to search for them.


Sturrock, Peter, A., Extraterrestrial Intelligent Life,
Quarterly Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society, Vol. 19, pp. 521-523, 1978.

Introductory paragraph - It appears that the search for extraterrestrial intelligence (ETI) is now a legitimate activity for astronomers and other scientists. This topic was recently reviewed on behalf of NASA by a panel of distinguished scientists led by professor Philip Morrison. Their primary conclusion is that, 'It is both timely and feasible to begin a serious search for intelligent extraterrestrial radio signals and also outline possible techniques for searching for planets associated with nearby stars (1).
1. Morrison, P., Billingham, J. & Wolfe, J. (eds), 1977. The Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence, SETI, NASA SP-419, National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Washington, DC.


Sturrock, Peter A., Uncertainty Estimates in the Number of Extraterrestrial Civilizations,
National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Grant NGR 05-020-668, SUIPR Report No. 808, March 1980. Proceedings of the Meeting, Montreal, Canada, August 15, 16, 1979. Dordrecht, D. Reidel Publishing Co., pp. 59-72, 1980.

Abstract - Estimation of the number N of communicative civilizations by means of Drake's formula involves the combination of several quantities, each of which is to some extent uncertain. The uncertainty in any quantity may be represented by a probability distribution function, even if that quantity is itself a probability. The uncertainty of current estimates of N is derived principally from uncertainty in estimates of the lifetime of advanced civilizations. It is argued that this is due primarily to uncertainty concerning the existence of a "Galactic Federation" which is in turn contingent upon uncertainty about whether the limitations of present-day physics are absolute or (in the event that there exists a yet-undiscovered "hyperphysics") transient. It is further argued that it is advantageous to consider explicitly these underlying assumptions in order to compare the probable numbers of civilizations operating radio beacons, permitting radio leakage, dispatching probes for radio surveillance or dispatching vehicles for manned surveillance.


Sturrock, Peter A., Science and the Weighing of Evidence,
Air Force Office of Scientific Research, Contract F44620-69-C-0008, National Aeronautics and Space Administration, Grant NGL 05-020-272, Office of Naval Research, Contract N00014-67-A-0112-005, SUIPR Report No. 413, 21 pages, 1971.

Abstract - Progress in science depends on the appraisal of hypotheses by reference to observational data. This procedure is formalized in such a way that judgments made by the theorists and judgments made by the observers may be combined to yield probabilities for the considered hypotheses.


Sturrock, Peter A., Carlson, J.B., Stanford workshop on extraterrestrial civilization - Opening a new scientific dialog - Conference Report

Origins of Life, Vol. 6, pp. 459-470, July 1975.


Teodorani M., Physical Data Acquisition and Analysis of Possible Flying Extraterrestrial Probes by using Opto-Electronic Devices,
Extraterrestrial Physics Review (EPR), Vol. 1, No. 3, pp. 32-37, 2000.
Teodorani M. and Strand E. P. Experimental Methods for Studying the Hessdalen-Phenomenon in the light of the Proposed Theories: a Comparative Overview
Rapport 1998:5, Høgskolen i Østfold (Norway), pp. 1-93, 1998.

Abstract - Unexplained plasma-like atmospheric "light balls" are observed at very low altitudes during alternate phases of maximum and minimum in the essdalen area, located in central Norway. Several theories are presented in order to explain the observed phenomenon; among these: piezo-electricity from rocks, atmospheric ionization triggered by solar activity, cosmic rays and extraterrestrial visitation. The presented study is aimed at proposing the use of a dedicated instrumental set-up, research experimental procedures and methods in order to prove or disprove every single theory: in this context several kinds of observational techniques, measurement strategies and physical tests of tactical relevance are discussed in detail. An introduction on any considered theory is presented together with a detailed discussion regarding the subsequent experimental phase. For each specific theory brief descriptions of the observable parameters and of the essential instrumental choices and a detailed discussion of measurement procedures coupled with suitable flow-charts, are presented.


Troitskii, V. S., On the Regularities of Development of ExtraTerrestrial Civilizations and the Search Strategy
IAF Paper 83-271, Pages: 4, 1983.

Abstract - Possible forms of energy conversion, technologies, and interstellar projects on which advanced extraterrestrial civilizations may be occupied are discussed. It is suggested that if life began evolving in the Universe 8-10 billion years ago, then some alien civilizations may be presently reshaping and building galaxies by now, although no astronomical evidence for such feats is presently available. Limiting factors for civilizations are light speed and dependence for thermal conditions on the distance to the home star. Energy limitations will encourage continual reconfiguring of a civilization's energy usage until the prime energy source is the home star, around which city-worlds could be built. The techniques would eventually lead to star travel because of the ability to reform and use energy. However, if life came into existence everywhere in the Universe simultaneously at the phase change after the Big Bang, then even millions of years could transpire before initial attempts to colonize the galaxy are enacted. The limitations on terrestrial technology and energy supplies would then be the equivalent of those in other civilizations, indicating that millimeter wave transmissions would have a chance at establishing contact.


Tough, Allen, Small Smart Interstellar Probes,
Journal of the British Interplanetary Society, Vol. 51, pp. 167-174, 1998.
Online Paper

Abstract - Humanity is making rapid progress in computers, robotics, nanotechnology and space exploration. Consequently, within 200 years, we will be likely to launch small interstellar probes containing highly advanced computers. Perhaps other civilizations, more advanced than ours, launched intelligent machines long ago to explore parts of our galaxy. One of their tiny probes may have already reached our planet in order to observe or monitor us. Our current scientific search for extraterrestrial intelligence should be expanded by adding a sophisticated search for such a probe. Two SETI "declarations of principles" have been developed to cover the search for radio and laser signals originating many light-years away. Some SETI scientists have assumed that these two declarations also apply to the scenario of discovering a nearby probe but, in fact, the fit is not very good. A separate set of "Procedures Following Detection of An Interstellar Probe" has been drafted.


Tough, Allen, What Role will Extraterrestrials play in Humanity's Future,
Journal of the British Interplanetary Society, Vol. 39, pp. 491-498, 1986.

Abstract - Because their capacities are probably highly advanced, some extraterrestrial species may be using unobtrusive methods of observing humankind and other fledgling civilisations in the Galaxy. The amount of help they want to give to such civilisations is probably quite significant. Their help could be of three types: instant intervention to avoid a nuclear holocaust or other imminent catastrophe; long-term help in reducing grave dangers; and help in improving nondangerous spheres of life. Sooner of later, unless we extinguish ourselves first, advanced extraterrestrials will have an enormous impact on humankind. Even during the next 30 years, the probability of contact or interaction may be one in four. Given these conclusions, what should we do next? Thirteen possible strategies are outlined. The likelihood and benefits of success are estimated for each strategy; then its overall priority is rated. At present, seven of the eight highest priority strategies remain neglected and unfunded.


Tough, Allen, Fresh SETI Strategies,
Journal of the British Interplanetary Society, Vol. 52, pp. 286-289, 1999.
Online Paper
Zuckerman, Ben; Hart, Michael, H. Extraterrestrials - Where are They?,
Cambridge University Press, Second Edition, 239 p., ISBN 0-521-44803-4, softback, 1995.

Chapter 7. Interstellar Propulsion Systems

Author: Freeman Dyson

Chapter Introductory Statement:

Chapter 8. Interstellar Travel: A Review

Author: Ian A. Crawford

Chapter 9. Settlements in Space, and Interstellar Travel

Author: Cliff Singer



Earth's Exploratory Probes Resources
Kilston, Steven,The Project: An Observatory/Transport Spaceship for Discovering and Populating Habitable Extrasolar Terrestrial Planets,
Ball Aerospace & Technologies Corp., 1999.
March 8, 1999 JPL Talk, Online Viewgraph Presentation (661 KB PDF)


 

Read more articles on this topic:

Interstellar Probes / SETV